PSA 10	$930 pop 15
PSA 9	$128 EST. pop 51
PSA 8.5	$73 EST. pop 2
PSA 8	$62 pop 53
PSA 7	$46 EST. pop 26
PSA 6	$36 EST. pop 22
PSA 5	$30 EST. pop 14
PSA 4	$24 EST. pop 4
PSA 3	$24 EST. pop —
PSA 2	$24 EST. pop —
PSA 1	$24 EST. pop 1

Base

$752

pop 32 @ PSA 10

Base pop 492

PSA 10	$752 pop 32
PSA 9	$109 EST. pop 122
PSA 9oc	$73 EST. pop —
PSA 8	$62 pop 139
PSA 7.5	$50 EST. pop 2
PSA 7	$49 pop 76
PSA 6	$28 pop 63
PSA 5.5	$28 EST. pop 1
PSA 5	$28 EST. pop 27
PSA 4	$25 EST. pop 6
PSA 3	$22 EST. pop —
PSA 2.5	$22 EST. pop 1
PSA 2	$20 EST. pop —
PSA 1	$18 EST. pop —

Grade: Parallel: Year:

On-the-record sales go back as far as PSA reports them — late 2017 for GPK — plus eBay-tracked and raw sales as they land.

Date	Price	Grade	Cert	Type
Loading…

Cross-Grader Values

Values across grading services for this card (BGS / SGC / CGC / others + Raw) — from cross-grader comps.

Grader	Grade	Value	Sales
Loading…

Grader vs PSA — % value difference at the same grade

Window:

Show:

Subject trend

Creepy Carol — across all cards

30 / 60 / 90 day momentum, every card we have for Creepy Carol

View subject →

🗑️ The Garbologist says…

Steady

The Garbologist sniffed around the sales pile.

5 recorded sales · 1 in the last year · trades only a few times a year · limited-confidence sample.
Following the trash: $447 → $470 → $256 → $400 → $980 — choppy but broadly rangebound.
Census check: PSA has graded 185 of this card, and only 8.1% come back a 10 — tough to gem.
Net-net, it's holding its ground — steady demand, no fireworks either way.

Automated analysis generated from this card’s real recorded sales and PSA population data — no opinions, no predictions guaranteed. Entertainment and research only, not financial advice.

Creepy Carol — across every card

Subject page →

Every Creepy Carol card we track — how the character is moving, not just this one grade.

🧬 Should I slab it?

SLAB IT

About a 8% gem (PSA 10) rate on this card's own PSA pop - graded pop is self-selected (best copies get submitted), so a random raw likely grades lower. Expected value ~$141 before the $80 PSA fee (fee only - excludes shipping & insurance), ~$61 after, vs a raw copy around $14 from 24 raw sales. Grading pencils out here, especially if you hit the $930 ten.

Gem (PSA 10) rate

8%

this card · 186 graded

PSA 10 value

$930

if you hit the ten

Grading cost

$80

PSA Regular tier

Expected after grade

$61

vs raw $14 from 24 raw sales

Probability-weighted across grades using PSA population (this card) as a proxy for cut & print quality, minus the grading fee. A guide, not a guarantee — centering and eye-appeal on your specific copy decide the grade.