All Years Creepy Carol — every card
54 cards tracked · 104 sales recorded · every card listed — even the ones that have never sold.
2 different characters carry this name
Creepy Carol · the picture also printed as Scary Carrie · first printed 1985 Garbage Pail Kids Original Series 1 #25A
Median sale $44 across 49 graded sales of 53 cards (last 12 months) · raw $10 across 199 raw sales · 1 year +75%
Creepy Carol · the picture printed opposite Haunted Hollis · first printed 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Beyond The Streets #10A
Top characters by median sale →
No graded sale on record of 1 card · raw $4 across 2 raw sales
| # | Card | Grade | Pop | GPK Price Guide Value | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | 32 | $752 PSA pop 32 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 4 | 6 | $25 PSA pop 6 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | 15 | $930 PSA pop 15 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25 |  |
PSA 8 | 1 | $92 PSA pop 1 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 7 | 6 | $15 PSA pop 6 |
eBay ↗ |
| 5A |  |
PSA 10 | 2 | $13 PSA pop 2 |
eBay ↗ |
| 5A | PSA 10 | — | $29 | eBay ↗ | |
| 5A | PSA 10 | — | $27 | eBay ↗ | |
| 5A | PSA 10 | — | $32 | eBay ↗ | |
| 5A | PSA 10 | — | $28 | eBay ↗ | |
| 5A | PSA 10 | — | $30 | eBay ↗ | |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | 2 | $35 PSA pop 2 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | 3 | $42 PSA pop 3 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | 2 | $66 PSA pop 2 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | 2 | $191 PSA pop 2 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | — | $71 | eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 9 | 2 | $20 PSA pop 2 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | — | No sales yet | eBay ↗ |
| 25A | PSA 9 | — | $32 | eBay ↗ | |
| 7A |  #7ACreepy Carol (2019) 2019 Garbage Pail Kids Series 2 Revenge Of Oh, The Horror-Ible Classic Monster Stickers |
PSA 10 | 3 | $33 PSA pop 3 |
eBay ↗ |
| 10A |  |
PSA 9 | 1 | $17 PSA pop 1 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | 6 | $54 PSA pop 6 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | 1 | $517 PSA pop 1 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 9 | 2 | $236 PSA pop 2 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A | PSA 10 | — | $77 | eBay ↗ | |
| 25A |  |
PSA 9 | 3 | $248 PSA pop 3 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A | PSA 10 | — | $815 | eBay ↗ | |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | 4 | $71 PSA pop 4 |
eBay ↗ |
| 25A |  |
PSA 10 | — | $543 | eBay ↗ |
| 25A | PSA 10 | — | $777 | eBay ↗ | |
| 25A | PSA 10 | — | $73 | eBay ↗ | |
| 7 |  |
PSA 10 | 9 | $36 PSA pop 9 |
eBay ↗ |
| 23A |  |
PSA 10 | — | $40 | eBay ↗ |
| 23A | PSA 10 | — | $255 | eBay ↗ | |
| 23A | PSA 10 | — | $119 | eBay ↗ | |
| 23A |  |
PSA 10 | — | $42 | eBay ↗ |
| 23A | PSA 10 | — | $113 | eBay ↗ | |
| 23A |  |
PSA 10 | 1 | $42 PSA pop 1 |
eBay ↗ |
| 23A | PSA 10 | — | $255 | eBay ↗ | |
| 23A |  |
PSA 10 | — | $93 | eBay ↗ |
| 23A | PSA 10 | 1 | $637 PSA pop 1 |
eBay ↗ | |
| 23A |  |
PSA 10 | — | $98 | eBay ↗ |
| 23A | PSA 10 | — | $255 | eBay ↗ | |
| 23A | PSA 10 | 1 | $383 PSA pop 1 |
eBay ↗ | |
| 23A |  |
PSA 10 | 1 | $42 PSA pop 1 |
eBay ↗ |
| 23A | PSA 10 | 1 | $103 PSA pop 1 |
eBay ↗ | |
| 23A | PSA 10 | — | $108 | eBay ↗ | |
| 23A | PSA 10 | — | $255 | eBay ↗ | |
| 6 | #6Creepy Carol (2025) 2025 Garbage Pail Kids Get A Grip Garbage Pail Kids Giant Art Prints Series 1 Never soldeBay ↗ |
PSA 10 | — | Never sold | eBay ↗ |
| 6 | #6Creepy Carol (2025) 2025 Garbage Pail Kids Get A Grip Garbage Pail Kids Giant Art Prints Series 1 Never soldeBay ↗ |
PSA 10 | — | Never sold | eBay ↗ |
| 6 | #6Creepy Carol (2025) 2025 Garbage Pail Kids Get A Grip Garbage Pail Kids Giant Art Prints Series 1 Never soldeBay ↗ |
PSA 10 | — | Never sold | eBay ↗ |
| 6 | #6Creepy Carol (2025) 2025 Garbage Pail Kids Get A Grip Garbage Pail Kids Giant Art Prints Series 1 Never soldeBay ↗ |
PSA 10 | — | Never sold | eBay ↗ |
| 6 |  #6Creepy Carol (2025) 2025 Garbage Pail Kids Get A Grip Garbage Pail Kids Giant Art Prints Series 1 Never soldeBay ↗ |
PSA 10 | — | Never sold | eBay ↗ |
| 6 | #6Creepy Carol (2025) 2025 Garbage Pail Kids Get A Grip Garbage Pail Kids Giant Art Prints Series 1 Never soldeBay ↗ |
PSA 10 | — | Never sold | eBay ↗ |
