This card30d 90d 1y All-time
Creepy Carol #25a 1985 Garbage Pail Kids Series 1 · PSA 10
View all Creepy Carol cards →PSA pop32
All grades · value and PSA population
10
$665
Pop 32 · 78 sales
9.5
—
Pop —
9
$150
Pop 122 · 57 sales
9 (OC)
$79
Pop — · 3 sales
9 (MC)
$70
Pop — · 3 sales
8.5
$46 EST.
Pop —
8
$61
Pop 138 · 54 sales
8 (OC)
$45
Pop — · 2 sales
7.5
$49 EST.
Pop 2
7
$47
Pop 77 · 20 sales
7 (ST)
$44
Pop — · 1 sale
6
$33
Pop 63 · 18 sales
5.5
$27 EST.
Pop 1
5
$22
Pop 27 · 2 sales
4
$23
Pop 6 · 2 sales
3
$21 EST.
Pop 4
2.5
$18 EST.
Pop 1
2
$17 EST.
Pop 3
1
$17 EST.
Pop —
cgc8
—
Pop —
CREEPY CAROL ACTIVE🟢 lowest on eBay: $5,017.95 all-in
🛒 24 listings on eBay now PSA 10 SLAB ×1 · RAW ×23
RAW (UNGRADED) — NOT A GRADED VALUE
$12
147 raw sales used for this value
view raw sales →
Front
Back
Price history · PSA 10
On-the-record sales go back as far as PSA reports them — late 2017 for GPK — plus eBay-tracked and raw sales as they land.
🗑️ The Garbologist says…
Cooling Off
The Garbologist sniffed around the sales pile.
- 78 recorded sales · 3 in the last year · trades about once a month · high-confidence sample.
- The recent trail reads $342 → $255 → $1,000 → $725 → $800 — ran up to a peak of $7,877, then cooled back off.
- Median moved -27% across the window ($808 → $588).
- Heads up: the last recorded sale ($800 on 2026-05-17) landed 20% above our current value — weigh it as a single data point.
- Census check: PSA has graded 471 of this card, and only 6.8% come back a 10 — tough to gem.
- Net-net, the heat is coming off — recent sales are softening. Could be a breather, could be a top; the trash doesn't say which.
Automated analysis generated from this card’s real recorded sales and PSA population data — no opinions, no predictions guaranteed. Entertainment and research only, not financial advice.
Creepy Carol — across every card
Subject page →Every Creepy Carol card we track — how the character is moving, not just this one grade.
🧬 Should I slab it?
Only if you're confident it's a 10Only about 1 in 15 copies of this card get a 10. A 10 is worth $665, but after the $92 cost it barely beats the $12 raw copy.
Expected value if graded$23 (after $92 all-in cost)
Raw value today$12 (from 147 raw sales)
VerdictOnly if you're confident it's a 10
Break-even: you need about a 5% chance of a PSA 10 (this card: 7%).
Chance of a PSA 10
7%
this card · 476 graded
PSA 10 value
$665
today · ~$665 by Feb 12, 2027
PSA 9 value
$150
today · ~$150 by Feb 12, 2027
All-in cost
$92
PSA fee $60 + shipping both ways $32
How these numbers work
All-in cost $92: PSA Standard tier fee $60 per card, insured shipping to PSA ~$12, PSA insured return shipping ~$20. Sending it to your PSA Vault instead skips return shipping (vault intake and storage are free): ~$72 all-in, so a graded copy would net ~$43.
Grade odds (this card, 476 PSA-graded): 10 · 7%, 9 · 26%, 8 · 29%, 7 or lower · 39%. People send their best copies, so a random raw copy usually grades a bit lower.
Values when it comes back (~95 days, about Feb 12, 2027): today's values (the set has no clear 3-month trend).
Expected value if graded = each grade's chance × its value, minus the all-in cost. A guide, not a guarantee — centering and corners on your copy decide the grade.
Grade odds (this card, 476 PSA-graded): 10 · 7%, 9 · 26%, 8 · 29%, 7 or lower · 39%. People send their best copies, so a random raw copy usually grades a bit lower.
Values when it comes back (~95 days, about Feb 12, 2027): today's values (the set has no clear 3-month trend).
Expected value if graded = each grade's chance × its value, minus the all-in cost. A guide, not a guarantee — centering and corners on your copy decide the grade.
Creepy Carol #25a 1985 Garbage Pail Kids Series 1 value by grade
| Grade | Value | Sales | PSA pop |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 | $665 | 78 | 32 |
| PSA 9 | $150 | 57 | 122 |
| PSA 9 (OC) | $79 | 3 | — |
| PSA 9 (MC) | $70 | 3 | — |
| PSA 8 | $61 | 54 | 138 |
| PSA 8 (OC) | $45 | 2 | — |
| PSA 7.5 | $49 est. | 0 | 2 |
| PSA 7 | $47 | 20 | 77 |
| PSA 7 (ST) | $44 | 1 | — |
| PSA 6 | $33 | 18 | 63 |
| PSA 5.5 | $27 est. | 0 | 1 |
| PSA 5 | $22 | 2 | 27 |
| PSA 3 | $21 est. | 0 | 4 |
| PSA 2.5 | $18 est. | 0 | 1 |
| PSA 2 | $17 est. | 0 | 3 |
Every grade of this card on one page. Est. = no sale at that grade yet. Tap a grade above to switch the whole page to it.
