All Years Scary Carrie — every card

50 cards tracked · 69 sales recorded · every card listed — even the ones that have never sold.
Every Scary Carrie appearance →GPK characters A–Z →
This character in numbers
Scary Carrie · the picture also printed as Creepy Carol · first printed 1985 Garbage Pail Kids Original Series 1 #25B
Median sale $55 across 42 graded sales of 50 cards (last 12 months) · raw $11 across 185 raw sales · 1 year +38%
Top characters by median sale →
#CardGradePopGPK Price Guide Value
25B
Scary Carrie (1985) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (1985) 1985 Garbage Pail Kids Original Series 1
PSA 9$130Pop 139eBay ↗
 PSA 9 139 $130
PSA pop 139
 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (1985) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (1985) 1985 Garbage Pail Kids Original Series 1 Glossy
PSA 10$962Pop 23eBay ↗
 PSA 10 23 $962
PSA pop 23
 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (1986) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (1986) 1986 Garbage Pail Kids Stickers-U.K. Minis
PSA 10$39Pop 8eBay ↗
 PSA 10 8 $39
PSA pop 8
 eBay ↗
5B
Scary Carrie (2011) #5B
#5BScary Carrie (2011) 2011 Garbage Pail Kids Flashback Series 2-Stickers
PSA 10$16Pop 2eBay ↗
 PSA 10 2 $16
PSA pop 2
 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2013) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1
PSA 10$35Pop 4eBay ↗
 PSA 10 4 $35
PSA pop 4
 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2013) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1 Atomic Refractor
PSA 10$92eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $92 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1 Autograph
PSA 10$72eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $72 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1 Cyan Printing Plate
PSA 10$295eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $295 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2013) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1 Gold Refractor
PSA 9$187Pop 5eBay ↗
 PSA 9 5 $187
PSA pop 5
 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2013) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1 Prism Refractor
PSA 9$17Pop 1eBay ↗
 PSA 9 1 $17
PSA pop 1
 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2013) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1 Refractor
PSA 10$34Pop 2eBay ↗
 PSA 10 2 $34
PSA pop 2
 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1 Superfractor
PSA 10$1,195eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $1,195 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2013) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1 Xfractor
PSA 9$39Pop 1eBay ↗
 PSA 9 1 $39
PSA pop 1
 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2013) 2013 Garbage Pail Kids Chrome Series 1 Yellow Printing Plate
PSA 10$295eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $295 eBay ↗
7B
Scary Carrie (2019) #7B
#7BScary Carrie (2019) 2019 Garbage Pail Kids Series 2 Revenge Of Oh, The Horror-Ible Classic Monster Stickers
PSA 10$34Pop 2eBay ↗
 PSA 10 2 $34
PSA pop 2
 eBay ↗
18A
#18AScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Bizarre Holidays
PSA 10$31eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $31 eBay ↗
18A
#18AScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Bizarre Holidays Blue
PSA 10$37eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $37 eBay ↗
18A
#18AScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Bizarre Holidays Deep Blue
PSA 10$37eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $37 eBay ↗
18A
#18AScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Bizarre Holidays Green
PSA 10$91eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $91 eBay ↗
18A
#18AScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Bizarre Holidays Light Green
PSA 10$37eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $37 eBay ↗
18A
#18AScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Bizarre Holidays Pink
PSA 10$37eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $37 eBay ↗
18A
#18AScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Bizarre Holidays Purple
PSA 10$110eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $110 eBay ↗
18A
#18AScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Bizarre Holidays Red
PSA 10$214eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $214 eBay ↗
18A
#18AScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Bizarre Holidays Yellow
PSA 10$37eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $37 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2020) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition
PSA 10$63Pop 4eBay ↗
 PSA 10 4 $63
PSA pop 4
 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2020) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition Gold
PSA 10$574eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $574 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition Green
PSA 10$87eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $87 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2020) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition Light Blue
PSA 9$35Pop 4eBay ↗
 PSA 9 4 $35
PSA pop 4
 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition Orange
PSA 10$459eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $459 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition Padparadscha
PSA 10$815eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $815 eBay ↗
25B
Scary Carrie (2020) #25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition Pink
PSA 10$83Pop 5eBay ↗
 PSA 10 5 $83
PSA pop 5
 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition Purple
PSA 9$275Pop 1eBay ↗
 PSA 9 1 $275
PSA pop 1
 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition Red
PSA 10$777eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $777 eBay ↗
25B
#25BScary Carrie (2020) 2020 Garbage Pail Kids Sapphire Edition Teal
PSA 10$83eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $83 eBay ↗
23B
Scary Carrie (2025) #23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary
PSA 10$95Pop 1eBay ↗
 PSA 10 1 $95
PSA pop 1
 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Black Printing Plate
PSA 10$255eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $255 eBay ↗
23B
Scary Carrie (2025) #23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Bloody Nose Red
PSA 9$219Pop 1eBay ↗
 PSA 9 1 $219
PSA pop 1
 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Booger Green
PSA 10$100eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $100 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Bruising Black
PSA 10$140eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $140 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Crumpled Garbage
PSA 10$100eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $100 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Cyan Printing Plate
PSA 10$255eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $255 eBay ↗
23B
Scary Carrie (2025) #23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Drool Blue
PSA 10$105eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $105 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Foilfractor
PSA 10$637eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $637 eBay ↗
23B
Scary Carrie (2025) #23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Fool's Gold
PSA 9$69Pop 1eBay ↗
 PSA 9 1 $69
PSA pop 1
 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Magenta Printing Plate
PSA 10$255eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $255 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Printing Plate
PSA 10$255eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $255 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Purple
PSA 10$100eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $100 eBay ↗
23B
Scary Carrie (2025) #23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Ruby
PSA 10$110eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $110 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Sour Orange
PSA 10$115eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $115 eBay ↗
23B
#23BScary Carrie (2025) 2025 Worst Of Garbage Pail Kids 40th Anniversary Yellow Printing Plate
PSA 10$255eBay ↗
 PSA 10 — $255 eBay ↗
GPK Price Guide
← Back